
Nobody needs a logic degree to answer an argument question. You need to find the gap between what is claimed and what is offered as proof.
Three parts of every argument
Any short argument in a test has the same shape.
- Conclusion: the claim the author wants you to accept.
- Evidence: the facts offered in support.
- Assumption: the unstated link that makes the evidence support the conclusion.
Most question types are a way of asking about that link. Find the conclusion first. Words like “therefore”, “so” and “clearly” often point to it, but not always, so ask what the author is trying to prove.
A worked example
A cafe changed its menu in April. Sales in May were 15% higher than in March. The owner concludes that the new menu caused the rise.
- Conclusion: the new menu caused the rise in sales.
- Evidence: sales rose after the menu changed.
- Assumption: nothing else explains the rise, so the menu is the cause.
That one gap lets you answer several question types.
Strengthen. Choose the option that makes the gap smaller. For example: “the cafe’s other costs and opening hours stayed the same”. That removes one alternative explanation.
Weaken. Choose the option that opens the gap. For example: “a large office opened next door in April”. Now a different reason for the rise is on the table.
Assumption. Choose what must be true for the argument to work. Test it with a negation: if the option were false, would the argument fall apart? “No other major change affected sales” passes that test.
Inference and flaw questions
Inference questions ask what follows from the statements. They are close to the deduction idea in our deduction guide: accept only what is forced. If the option adds a fact, it fails.
Flaw questions ask what is wrong with the reasoning. Common flaws are confusing cause with timing, treating a sample as the whole, and treating something necessary as enough. In the cafe argument, the flaw is that coming after the change does not prove coming from the change.
Boldface questions ask what role a highlighted phrase plays: evidence, conclusion, objection or background. Name each role before you look at the options.
Traps to name
- Too extreme: the option uses “always”, “never” or “only” when the argument claims less.
- Out of scope: the option is interesting but concerns a different subject.
- Reversed: the option strengthens when you were asked to weaken.
- Half true: the option starts well and ends in a claim the argument doesn’t need.
A good habit is to say the type aloud in your head: “weaken, so I want something that opens the gap.” Then scan the options for gap-openers only.
Practise it
The Verbal Ability and Reasoning course teaches these types in Unit 9, one move for each, with every option explained. The previous guide, name the question first, covers reading questions in the same spirit.
Quick FAQ
Do I need to know formal logic terms?
No. Plain words are enough: conclusion, evidence, assumption, gap.
Is the stronger answer always the more detailed one?
No. The best answer is the one that deals with the gap, not the one with the most words.
Which exams use these questions?
Several tests include critical reasoning or argument questions in some form. Check your test’s own description for what it includes.
Official sources
GMAT is a trademark of GMAC. GRE is a trademark of ETS. Prepspire is independent and not affiliated.
Keep going: the Verbal Ability course, free taster courses and free sample tests.
