Logical Reasoning: Deduction and Arrangements

Cover image for the article: Logical Reasoning: Deduction and Arrangements

Two questions can use the same words and need opposite habits. Decide which type you have before you pick up a pencil.

Two types, two habits

Deduction questions give you statements and ask what must be true, what could be true, or what cannot be true. The habit is cautious: accept only what the statements force.

Arrangement questions give you clues about a row, a table or a schedule and ask who or what goes where. The habit is constructive: fix what is certain first, then narrow what remains.

Naming the type takes five seconds and saves minutes. It also stops you applying the wrong habit, such as guessing an arrangement when the question only asked what is certain.

Deduction: what must be true

Read this one slowly.

All the volunteers wore badges. Some of the people who wore badges were students.

Which of these must be true?

  • Some volunteers were students.
  • Some students wore badges.
  • All students were volunteers.

Only the second must be true, because the second sentence says it outright. The first could be true, but the statements don’t force it: the students with badges may all have been visitors. The third goes much too far.

The trap here is a plausible conclusion that the statements permit but don’t require. Ask of each option: is there any way the statements could be true and this option false? If there is, it does not have to be true.

Arrangements: fix the certain things first

Four friends sit in a row of four seats, numbered 1 to 4 from the left.

  1. Mia sits somewhere to the left of Noor.
  2. Omar sits next to Noor.
  3. Pia does not sit at either end.
  4. Omar does not sit in seat 4.

Start with clue 3, the one that gives a firm restriction. Pia is in seat 2 or seat 3.

If Pia is in seat 2: seats 1, 3 and 4 remain. Omar and Noor must be next to each other, and the only neighbouring pair left is seats 3 and 4. Omar can’t take seat 4, so Omar is in seat 3 and Noor in seat 4. Mia is in seat 1, which is to the left of Noor. This works.

If Pia is in seat 3: seats 1, 2 and 4 remain. The only neighbouring pair is seats 1 and 2, so Omar and Noor fill those and Mia must be in seat 4. But Mia has to be left of Noor, so this fails.

The only valid order is Mia, Pia, Omar, Noor. Trying all 24 possible orders confirms that no other order satisfies every clue.

What to take from it

  • Test each possibility the clues leave open, one at a time. Two or three cases are usually enough.
  • Write the row down, even as four boxes. Holding it in your head is where people lose track.
  • Use the strongest clue first, here the one about the end seats.
  • Always check your final order against every clue, including the ones you used early.

Common traps

  • Treating “next to” as “to the left of” or the reverse.
  • Treating “somewhere to the left” as “immediately to the left”.
  • Reading “some” as “some but not all”.
  • Stopping at the first case that works without checking the other case, when the question asks what must be true.

These are the slips the Logical and Non-verbal Reasoning course names in its wrong-option explanations. If you want a sense of how this thinking connects to numbers, data sufficiency beyond the GMAT asks a related question: is what I know enough?

Quick FAQ

Should I draw a diagram every time?

For arrangements, yes. A rough grid or row costs seconds and prevents mistakes. For simple deduction, a short list of possible and impossible cases is often enough.

What if a clue seems to allow two answers?

Then you probably have a missing case. Go back and try each possibility the clues leave open.

Are these puzzles on the GMAT or GRE?

Reasoning forms part of both, but each test has its own formats. Read the official descriptions rather than assuming.

Official sources

GMAT is a trademark of GMAC. GRE is a trademark of ETS. Prepspire is independent and not affiliated.

Keep going: the Logical Reasoning course, free taster courses and free sample tests.